Muse of Fire ([info]muse0fire) wrote,
@ 2008-03-02 08:01:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Current location:At home
Current mood: awake
Entry tags:book review, entertainment, husband, movie review, random day, travel

No country for chicks who prefer to pretend that life is beautiful
Happy (day after) Birthday to [info]moxiegirl  !

I just finished reading No Country for Old Men by Cormac McCarthy. I can honestly say I have no desire to see the film. It's an excellent book, but...

... the cruelty is difficult for me to take. I agree with the sentiments expressed by Sheriff Bell that things seem to be getting worse, in terms of a callous disregard for other people. He says at one point that it begins with the loss of civility, and I think he has an excellent point. I believe - and I may be completely naive here - that there used to be some codes of honor which were even followed by many criminals, such as not killing or harming women or children. This is not to say that it's ok to harm grown men, but at least the "no women or kids" (thank you Leon) engaged some sort of limit which has now seemingly gone completely. It's a way to calculate the true cold-bloodedness and evil - think of the Nazis willingness to kill women, kids, and the infirm. I suppose it comes from the notion that grown men can generally - or are expected to - fight for themselves, whereas women and kids generally do not have the physical upperhand. And it's a thin thread, but a thread nonetheless, that having some respect for the life of those who can't defend themselves gives someone some small hint of morality to cling to, and perhaps a tenuous connection to civilization and humanity.

What does this rant have to do with Old Country? The central figure in the book, Anton Chigurh, is a cold-blooded killer who doesn't hesitate to kill anyone. And I have a hard time enjoying that determined and chilling action. For those of you who have seen the movie, but not read the book: in the book, Carla Jean, the wife of Llewellyn Moss, does not talk Chigurh out of killing her. He takes out a coin and tells her to call it, she calls heads, it lands on tails. He kills her. (Edit: I thought, in reading the Wikipedia description, that this had been changed in the movie, but it appears I was wrong, and the filmmakers just made it more ambiguous - that sounds to me like an excellent choice.)

I think perhaps the reason I have such a hard enjoying this is because I believe that this kind of violence and murder does occur, and that is disturbing. If I thought it was an exaggerated lack of morality or humane empathy, I could more easily relax and enjoy the excellent writing and careful plotting.

And this is not to say that I want to stick my head in a hole and pretend evil does not exist. But when I'm confronted with such things - in my hotel room the other day I made the mistake of watching an ABC documentary on child prostitution in Cambodia - I start to think that perhaps it's better that I only have cats, because what kind of world would I be bringing a child into? Is it really a case of a memory filter that makes it seem to everyone as though the world is going downhill, when in reality there's always been the same level of evil but expressed in different ways?

And this, ladies and gentlemen, is why I do not want to see a movie where the central character (who I'm sure is incredibly well acted based on the reviews) is a coldhearted unredeemable killer.


On a completely different wave, I also re-watched Peter's Friends, which, while charming and featuring a terrific cast of wonderful actors (Stephen Fry, Hugh Laurie, Emma Thompson, Kenneth Branaugh, and many more), now seems like a very dated and British version of The Big Chill. It's lovely to watch this talented cast interact, and of course for those of us now used to seeing Hugh Laurie as the cynical American doctor on House, it's great to be reminded of his musical and comedy abilities (although he gets a chance to use his drama chops, as well.) What seems dated is the death knell that sounds when Peter announces he is HIV positive: I think it's a wonderful thing to be able to say that 16 years later it is no longer the absolute death sentence that it was. Thank goodness for modern medicine.

And finally, Husband and I were invited by the neighbors to spend Saturday playing kickball in a tournament (and drinking beer, beginning at 10 AM.) Considering that was the only sport in elementary school for which I did NOT get picked last, it was quite fun. I'm pretty sure it's been 25 years (ye gods that makes me feel old) since I played it last.

With March 1 comes the loss of my Gold Medallion status on Delta... I'm now only Silver, which essentially makes me a peon. It means I'll no longer get frequently upgraded, and will have to be content being squeezed into coach with the rest of you lot. Actually the only real reason I really like the upgrades is NOT for the alcohol or larger seats (I'm small enough that coach is generally fine in that regard) - it's for the meals served on longer flights. Totally worth it when it means an actual full meal with protein, vegetable, starch and dessert - instead of a pack of crackers, something that passes for spreadable "cheese", and a teensy box with about 8 raisins. Ah, woe is me. I somehow think I'll survive; I just had to whine a little.
.



(5 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]curt_holman
2008-03-02 02:14 pm UTC (link)
"now seems like a very dated and British version of The Big Chill"

I remember that it seemed like that on its opening weekend, actually.

"in the book, Carla Jean, the wife of Llewellyn Moss, does not talk Chigurh out of killing her."

Hmm, you may be misinformed as to how the movie ends. (I suppose its ambiguous, but it seems pretty clear to me that the resolution is the same.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]muse0fire
2008-03-02 02:21 pm UTC (link)
Hmm, you may be misinformed as to how the movie ends.

Ah, ok. I read the Wikipedia plot detail of the movie, and thought that what was was implied. My mistake! In that case it sounds like they made a good choice for the film, if it was slightly ambiguous.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]baldsug
2008-03-02 06:42 pm UTC (link)
I understand not wanting to see it - it's the same reason I don't care to see the film "Happiness". Having said that, I would just offer that in the hands of the Coen bros, it's a pretty damn impressive film. The performances across the board are phenomenal - not just Bardem, but Jones and Josh Brolin in particular. Chigurh is not the main character in the film...he's a force He's a thing that's out there that everyone has to comment and react to and deal with as the embodiment of that sort of evil. It may even do a better job of that than the book cause it doesn't ask you to try and get inside his head.

Also, one other spoiler note - in the film Carla Jean refuses to call the coin which I like even better saying "It's not the coin, it's just you. You decide to do this."

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]muse0fire
2008-03-03 12:53 am UTC (link)
Hm. Ok, it sounds like a strong interpretation, and worth seeing after all. I had no doubts about the quality of the film from all the raves, but you're saying the movie actually adds a level, so yes, sounds like I should add it to my list after all.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]doczauthor
2008-03-03 07:15 pm UTC (link)
I haven't read the book, only seen the movie, but the movie is worth seeing. As Baldsug points out Chigurh is not the main character, with Jones and Brolin as the narrative focus. I'd say that 90% of the movie is fantastic, but (IMHO) it falters in its waning moments and serves up an ambiguous ending. Is it Brolin's movie? Jones' movie? Or was it really all about Chigurh after all? I do want to see it again at some point to ponder this question, but I'll wait until I can netflix it. There's some very fine film-making on display (although I wouldn't have picked it for best picture.)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(5 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…